Authors: John Bowers; Gillian Mould
Addresses: Stirling Management School, University of Stirling, FK9 5LA, Stirling, UK ' Stirling Management School, University of Stirling, FK9 5LA, Stirling, UK
Abstract: Considerable effort has been expended in improving the health service in the UK through a focus on quantifiable targets. This paper examines the specific experience of the introduction of a new staff rota designed to help reduce the time patients spend in the emergency department at one hospital. A simple comparison of the mean times suggested a significant improvement in the service. However, there had been substantial changes in the environment and an analysis of covariance, incorporating the volume of activity and the doctors' experience, suggested that the new staff rota had differential benefits for different categories of patients: some had a reduction of 16 minutes in their mean time though others were unaffected. This example illustrates the challenges of measuring the impact of service redesign in healthcare even when a well defined innovation is considered and the impact is restricted to a readily quantified measure.
Keywords: healthcare mangement; National Health Service; NHS; UK; United Kingdom; hospital emergency departments; service redesign; targets; patient waits; treatment times; staff rotas; matching capacity-demand; capacity; demand; waiting times; new staff rota introduction; differential benefits; impact measurement.
International Journal of Services Technology and Management, 2013 Vol.19 No.4/5/6, pp.254 - 266
Available online: 30 Jul 2013 *Full-text access for editors Access for subscribers Purchase this article Comment on this article