Title: A comparative study of MPC and optimised PID control

Authors: Fawzan M. Salem; Mohamed I. Mosaad; Mohamed A. Awadallah

Addresses: Electronics Research Institute (ERI), Cairo, Egypt; Yanbu Industrial College, Saudi Arabia ' Higher Technological Institute (HTI), 10th of Ramadan City, Egypt; Yanbu Industrial College, Saudi Arabia ' University of Zagazig, Zagazig, Egypt; Ryerson University, Canada

Abstract: The paper presents a comparative study between the performance of model predictive control (MPC) and optimised proportional-integral-differential (PID) control on different systems. An objective function derived from rise time, settling time, percentage overshoot, and steady-state error is minimised in order to obtain the gains of the PID controller. The bacterial foraging (BF) algorithm is used to tune the parameters of the PID controller through performance optimisation of the system. System performance characteristics are compared to another controller designed based on MPC. The rise time, settling time, percentage overshoot, integral absolute error (IAE), and integral time-multiplied absolute error (ITAE) of the controllers are compared when acting on systems of different orders. Controller testing and performance comparison are carried out on first, second, third, forth, and fifth order systems. Results indicate that MPC consistently outperforms optimised PID control in all cases.

Keywords: model predictive control; MPC; optimal control; PID controller; bacterial foraging optimisation; BFO; performance characteristics; performance evaluation; rise time; settling time; percentage overshoot; integral absolute error; IAE; integral time-multiplied absolute error; ITAE.

DOI: 10.1504/IJIED.2015.076293

International Journal of Industrial Electronics and Drives, 2015 Vol.2 No.4, pp.242 - 250

Received: 27 Oct 2015
Accepted: 20 Dec 2015
Published online: 30 Apr 2016 *

Full-text access for editors Full-text access for subscribers Purchase this article Comment on this article