The fungibility of criminal guilt and political association: First Amendment rights, the Liberty City Seven and the Material Support Provision of the AEDPA
by G.E. Gollrad
International Journal of Liability and Scientific Enquiry (IJLSE), Vol. 4, No. 1, 2011

Abstract: The prohibition on 'lending material support' to terrorist organisations in the Material Support Provision (MSP) of the Anti-Terrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act allows courts to circumvent established First Amendment jurisprudence and violate freedom of speech and free association. While on its surface, the MSP may not abridge First Amendment rights, it is not limited in scope. For example, the MSP functions in conjunction with the designation procedure that grants the executive the power to decide which organisations are 'terrorist' and which are not. The Liberty City Seven case is illustrative: the defendants were prosecuted and convicted for engaging in First Amendment activity despite the fact that their alleged violations of the law never threatened any imminent lawless action, nor reached any point where they were likely to do so. This article analyses the MSP's impact on First Amendment protections by assessing the rational government purpose argument, and the government's 'fungibility' argument – that any support to a designated foreign terrorist organisation advances its illegal goals because all forms of support are 'fungible'. This article concludes that the MSP's scope should be narrowed so that it cannot reach political speech or associative conduct devoid of true criminal act or intent.

Online publication date: Sat, 29-Nov-2014

The full text of this article is only available to individual subscribers or to users at subscribing institutions.

 
Existing subscribers:
Go to Inderscience Online Journals to access the Full Text of this article.

Pay per view:
If you are not a subscriber and you just want to read the full contents of this article, buy online access here.

Complimentary Subscribers, Editors or Members of the Editorial Board of the International Journal of Liability and Scientific Enquiry (IJLSE):
Login with your Inderscience username and password:

Username:        Password:          Forgotten your password?

Want to subscribe?
A subscription gives you complete access to all articles in the current issue, as well as to all articles in the previous three years (where applicable). See our Orders page to subscribe.

If you still need assistance, please email subs@inderscience.com