Article Abstract

|
Title: |
An ethical analysis of the precautionary principle |
| |
Author: |
Marc A. Saner
|
| |
Address: |
Ethics & Policy Issues Centre, Department of Philosophy, Carleton University, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, ON, K1S 5B6, Canada |
| |
Journal: |
International Journal of Biotechnology 2002 - Vol. 4, No.1 pp. 81-95 |
| |
Abstract: |
The debate over the precautionary principle is intimately linked with values and worldviews. I examine how diverging conceptions of ''the good world'' affect the conceptualisation of the precautionary principle. Three complementary conceptualisations emerge; 1) a call for a change in attitude, 2) a prescription for formalistic action and 3) guidance for contextual action. I apply these conceptualisations to two extreme forms of implementations, a minimal and maximum change approach. I conclude by conducting risk evaluations of the second order. What are the risks of implementing the precautionary principle into risk evaluation? |
| |
Keywords: |
precautionary principle; ethics; analysis; meaning; contextual; formalistic; paradox; Pascal|s Wager; Buridan|s Ass; risk assessment; risk management. |
| |
DOI: |
10.1504/IJBT.2002.000181 |
| |
Purchase this Paper Comment on the Paper
|
| | |